Cafe Milano Pizzeria and Restaurant

Cafe Milano Pizzeria and Restaurant stands as a beloved Italian dining destination right in the heart of Staten Island at 401 Forest Ave. Revered for its authentic flavors and warm, inviting atmosphere, this family-friendly restaurant masters the art of Italian cuisine with an emphasis on classic comfort foods that keep locals and visitors coming back time and again.

Step inside to experience a cozy, bustling environment perfect for casual meals with family or friends. The aroma of freshly baked pizza dough mingles enticingly with hints of garlic, herbs, and melting cheese, instantly sparking your appetite. Whether you’re craving a hearty pie or a vibrant salad, Cafe Milano delivers with passion and precision.

The menu showcases crowd-pleasers that celebrate traditional Italian fare alongside creative specialties. Their pizza lineup is exceptional, featuring standout options like the creamy Vodka Pie topped with mozzarella and fresh basil, the fresh and vibrant Fresh Mozzarella with Basil & Tomato, and the indulgent Shrimp Pizza available with both white or red sauce. Each pizza arrives with a perfectly cooked crust—crispy on the outside yet tender and well-supported beneath, preventing any floppy slices, just as one delighted customer praised.

Beyond pizza, there’s an array of tasting experiences for all palates. The Seafood Platter Alla Marinara bursts with briny flavors from the sea, while the Orichetti Pasta with Sausage and Tortellini Alla Rosa are rich, comforting dishes that embrace the depth of classic Italian sauces. Friendly reviews consistently highlight the satisfying portions and great prices, an excellent combination that speaks to the restaurant’s dedication to value and quality.

Salad lovers are equally well catered for with fresh options like the Grilled Shrimp Salad, where tender shrimp sit atop crisp greens dressed in a zesty vinaigrette, or the hearty Grilled Chicken Caesar that balances crunchy romaine and parmesan with just the right creamy dressing. For a lighter yet equally flavorful start, try the Spinach Salad with Grilled Chicken Caesar or the vibrant Greek Salad.

Those looking for portable, delicious options will appreciate the large and medium calzones filled with a generous blend of cheeses and choice add-ons, perfect for sharing or savoring solo. The BBQ Chicken Pie and Meatball calzones combine robust flavors encased in golden, perfectly baked crusts that bring a comforting heartiness to the table.

Customer experiences reflect Cafe Milano’s unwavering commitment to excellence. Joseph Iacono raves about their perfectly cooked pizza with an “excellent undercarriage” and sauce that beautifully complements the dough without any flop—a true mark of skillful preparation. Mikeywow’s first visit turned into a firm guarantee of return visits, commending not just the food but also the welcoming and attentive staff who truly enhance the dining experience.

Longtime patrons like Alexandra M. appreciate the consistent quality and generous portions, keeping them coming back from their home on Staten Island’s South Shore despite inconvenient parking, knowing the food makes the trip worthwhile. Joan Breen’s note on frequent takeout orders and seamless large family dinners highlights the restaurant’s versatility as both a convenient meal hub and a warm spot for memorable gatherings.

Whether stopping by for a casual slice, opting for a family meal, or arranging catering for a special occasion, Cafe Milano Pizzeria and Restaurant offers a delightful Italian dining experience that satisfies cravings and creates lasting impressions with every bite.

For a taste of Staten Island’s best Italian comfort food, call +1 718-720-1313 or visit Cafe Milano Pizzeria and Restaurant at 401 Forest Ave today. Prepare to be welcomed, indulged, and impressed by a menu that truly celebrates the heart of Italian cooking.